Daniel Keefe, Summer 2025 Intern, at the MTF Office

Since 2009, The Rome Experience—an initiative of Midwest Theological Forum—has introduced seminarians to the heart of the Church through a 6-week summer program, complementing their diocesan formation, invigorating their vocations, and enlivening their fidelity to the Holy Father. During their time in Rome, the seminarians visit several Vatican Dicasteries, including the Apostolic Penitentiary. Here they had the opportunity to meet with Msgr. Carlos Encina Commentz, an official of the Penitentiary and author of the new book When and How to Have Recourse to the Apostolic Penitentiary, available from MTF.

Read about this experience from participant Jacob Schneider, seminarian for the Diocese of Evansville:

On a sunny Wednesday morning, halfway through the fifth week of The Rome Experience, we had an opportunity to visit and learn about the Apostolic Penitentiary. The current facilities were established during the 16th century, with the tribunal itself founded during the 13th century at the earliest. Despite its title, the Apostolic Penitentiary focuses not on housing offenders that are of interest to the Holy See, but rather on reviewing cases for clerics that only the Holy See can provide a response towards, and if need be, a penance.In the words of Msgr. Encina, who serves for the Penitentiary, contrary to the publicly declared excommunications, the penitentiary is "a tribunal of the internal forum" and, therefore, cases that would not be directly known by the public. Such scenarios would include excommunications where a priest broke the seal of confession or profaned the Holy Eucharist. Msgr. Encina offered a thorough description as to the nature of such cases that would be grounds for excommunication, and the process in which clerics would need to appeal for absolution and penance.

We had the opportunity to dive more into how we, once ordained priests, will best be able to protect the internal form that the penitentiary strongly defends and upholds for the Church and her people. As a matter of fact, we were quite curious about the seal of confession, given that Msgr. Encina states how breaking the seal of confession is one of the most common appeals they receive.

Given our curiosity, he directed our attention toward a book that he had been working on for some time now, which is a book with almost everything anyone (clergy and laity) would want to know about confession from A to Z. The work has been published in three languages and will soon be published in English and a few others very soon.

For his position at the Penitentiary, Msgr. Encina is deeply versed and heavily trained in canon law and takes his duties seriously, and yet with great joy. While speaking with us on the nature of his responsibilities, he was quite confident on the importance for seminarians to take the opportunity to learn more on canon law if we were able.

Overall, the work of the Penitentiary shows how the Vatican takes the duties and sanctity of her clergy and the sacred nature of her sacraments very seriously, ultimately working toward the salvation of souls. This motivation, Msgr. Encina recalls, is the last canon in the Code of Canon Law, and from what he has demonstrated by his profession and vocation, it is the motto of the Penitentiary, which reflects the motto of the Church.

 

Jacob Schneider
Rome Experience Class of 2025
Diocese of Evansville

Titles Published by MTF

Jesus Our Redeemer by Fr. Peter Armenio

When and How to Have Recourse to the Apostolic Penitentiary

The Tribunal of Mercy, which is the Apostolic Penitentiary, is the oldest institution of the Roman Curia. Its fundamental role is bringing back penitents into the embrace of the Heavenly Father and the life of grace. In this practical and essential guide, Msgr. Carlos Encina, an Official of the Penitentiary, explains the structure and functions of the Tribunal and when and how to have recourse to it.

View Details

Our Moral Life in Christ by Fr. Peter Armenio

Cuándo y cómo recurrir a la Penitenciaría Apostólica

El Tribunal de la Misericordia, que es la Penitenciaría Apostólica, es la institución más antigua de la Curia Romana. Su papel fundamental es traer de vuelta a los penitentes al abrazo del Padre Celestial y a la vida de la gracia. En esta guía práctica e imprescindible, Mons. Carlos Encina, un Oficial de la Penitenciaría, explica la estructura y las funciones del tribunal, así como cuándo y cómo recurrir a él.

View Details